Member-only story

Be Careful What You Wish For

“Gender Critical” Feminists may exalt motherhood — but they are playing a dangerous game with women’s rights

jane fae
6 min readJun 27, 2021
Adapted from The Miraculous Lactation of Saint Bernard, by Alonso Cano ( c. 1650): Public Domain

The recent onslaught on trans people has seen self-identified feminists taking on board some dodgy politics. In bed with the far right and Christian fundamentalists, they re-assure themselves — and friends — that this is an alliance of convenience, to be ditched when the “trans menace” is eliminated.

Defining women as mothers, and going large on motherhood is quite another matter.

It is wishful thinking, that overlooks the plans these groups have for women as a class. It ignores the fact that fascism is for life — and not just for Christmas (other seasons are available).

Now read on.

That old pianist joke

Ah. Wishful thinking! It is natural to wish. So, popular culture is awash with cautionary tales of the price paid when you wish first and think consequence second. One of the earliest (adult) jokes I remember, from my local student rag mag, was the tale of yet another man who walks into a pub and… pulls a miniature piano and twelve-inch pianist from his pocket! (yes: it’s an old and very bad pun about male wish-fulfilment and a hard-of-hearing genie!).

--

--

jane fae
jane fae

Written by jane fae

Feminist, writer, campaigner on political and sexual liberty who also knows a bit about IT, the law and policing. Not entirely serious…

Responses (2)